Shelter Island shopkeepers have been busy preparing for the early summer season. After a year-plus of isolation, we could all use something fresh for our wardrobe or home, and you’re sure to find something in one our Island’s terrific shops! Here’s a tour of what’s open (alphabetically) at the un-official start of summer:
This gem of an independent bookstore, Finley’s Fiction features the newest fiction and non-fiction – bestsellers, literary wonders, debut authors, biographies/memories, political non-fiction, as well as beautiful coffee table books. The children’s section has stories for budding new readers and young teen fiction. The store has toys, games, puzzles, and gift options, too. Hours: Friday to Sunday, 10 AM to 5 PM. 8 Grand Avenue | 203-650-7616 | finelysfiction.com
Did you know that the Gardiner’s Bay Country Club Pro Shop is open to the public? Find sports apparel, accessories and equipment for men, women and kids. The shop carries yoga and tennis wear, and more. Club attire required. Hours: 8 AM to 5 PM daily. 12 Dinah Rock Road | 631-749-1033 | Follow the GBCC Pro Shop on Facebook
For gardening and lawn needs, visit Grady Riley Gardens with new nursery arrivals as well as soil amendments, mulches and other bulk goods, and a great selection of gardening tools and equipment. Find planter boxes, grasses and much more. 80 North Menantic Road | 631-749-5575
Sign up for a flower share at Island Time Farm and get 10 gorgeous bouquets, one per week from July through Labor Day, perfect for your home or business, or to give as a gift. “Nothin’ better than grown on Shelter Island flowers,” owner Kelci McIntosh says. The remaining spots are $50 per week. To join, call/text 425-879-6939 or send an email. 62 North Ferry Road | Follow Island Time Farm on Facebook
Visit Kanela Handmade, Karen Springer’s pop-up shop specializing in Colombian and Costa Rican hand-crafted, fair trade products. Apparel, jewelry and accessory selections include perfect items for the beach or an evening out. Beautiful nature-inspired decor includes beach art, paintings and more. 16 St. Mary’s Road | 917-971-6156 | Follow Kanela Handmade on Instagram
Browse Marika’s Eclectic Boutique for the unique, vintage home furnishing items on the lawn, under the tents and inside the house and barns. Furniture, lamps, tables, art and more, plus painting and upholstery services. Drop in daily, or by appointment. 401-862-6607 | 6 South Ferry Road | Follow on Instagram
Visit silversmith and jewelry maker Mimi Page in her very cool Argosy Airstream studio to check out unique designs handmade in sterling silver with details like wrapped sea glass and beach stones. Call for an appointment. 5 West Neck Road | 631-935-3134 |Follow Mimi Page Jewelry on Instagram
At Pure Soul, owner Sylma Cabrera offers gorgeous clothing, jewelry and accessories curated for Island comfort and style, as well as unique home decor and hostess gifts. Opens for the season on Thursday, May 27 then daily 10 AM to 5 PM. 183 North Ferry Road (Bridge Street) | 516-413-4136 | Follow Pure Soul on Instagram
The new SALT Market at the Island Boatyard (next door to SALT Waterfront Bar and Grill) carries branded apparel, including hoodies, hats and T-shirts, as well as grab-and-go goodies and other essentials for boaters. 63 South Menantic Road | 631-749-5355 | saltshelterisland.com
Pop in at the Shelter Island Country Club Pro Shop for Greg Norman apparel and accessories to outfit yourself before a game on the public course. Carts and clubs available for rental, too. Follow this link to learn about membership. Hours: 10 AM to 5 PM. 26 Sunnyside Avenue | 631-749-0416 | shelterislandcc.org
Browse unique creations by Anthony Peronce inside his studio at the family’s Shelter Island IGA. He’s got the grooviest sweatshirts around! Hours: 7 AM to 7 PM. 75 North Ferry Road | 631-749-0382 | Follow Anthony Peronce on Facebook
The Shelter Island Heights Pharmacy has a great selection of Island souvenirs, including its own branded Soda/Drugs items, and gifts and cards for any occasion. You’ll also find a full-range of health and beauty products, as well as the Island’s only pharmacy counter. Hours: Monday to Friday, 8:30 AM to 6 PM; Saturday to 5 PM, Sunday to 12:30 PM. 19 Grand Avenue | 631-749-0445 | shelterislandpharmacy
With fashions for the home and to wear, SIMMS carries the iconic Marie Eiffel line and other boutique designers. Unique art, decor, gifts and home furnishings. Hours: Friday to Monday, 10 AM to 5 PM or by appointment. 181 North Ferry Road | 631-749-5067 | Follow SIMMS on Instagram
“Chat plants with us” at White Oak Farm & Gardens. Knowledgeable staff will help you find plants work best for different levels of sun exposure, and provide other gardening tips. “We do our best to ensure your garden success!” Hours: Thursday to Sunday, 10 AM to 5 PM or by appointment. 74 North Ferry Road | 631-749-5914 | whiteoakfarmsandgardens.com
