The Suffolk County Board of Elections is providing unofficial election results by election district. Absentee ballot counting is ongoing. We will update the results as new figures become available. Or watch them at https://apps2.suffolkcountyny.gov/boe.
Results by district
Below are the unofficial results, including breakdowns by party line, from Shelter Island’s four election districts. Click links to skip to results by race: Town Justice, U.S. President, U.S. Congress, NYS Senate, NYS Assembly, Justice of the Supreme Court 10th District, Proposals and Uncontested Races (County Court and Family Court).
Party line key: C Conservative, D Democratic, G Green, I Independence, L Libertarian, R Republican, PTT Protect the Taxpayer, WF Working Families
Town Justice
In the race for Town Justice, challenger Stanley I. Birnbaum, who ran on the Democratic line, got 852 votes (53.73%); incumbent Helen J. Rosenblum, who ran on the Republican line, got 731 votes (46.09%). These are unofficial results.
| Shelter Island Election District | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Total |
| Birnbaum | 201 | 239 | 201 | 211 | 852 |
| Rosenblum | 183 | 205 | 152 | 191 | 731 |
U.S. President
In the race for U.S. President and Vice President, incumbent Donald R. Trump, who ran on the Republican and Conservative lines, got 333,617 (55.49%) votes county-wide. Challengers Joseph R. Biden and Kamala D. Harris, who ran on the Democratic and Working Families lines, got 259,463 (43.15%) votes county-wide. Howie Hawkins/Angela Nicole Walker, Green, 1,496 county-wide; Jo Jorgensen/Jeremy Cohen, Libertarian, 3,578; and Brock Pierce/Karla Ballard, Independence, 1,961.
On Shelter Island, the Biden/Harris ticket got 1,053 votes (64.64%) votes to the Trump/Pence ticket’s 576 votes (35.36%). These are unofficial results.
| Shelter Island Election District | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Total |
| Biden/Harris | 246 | 298 | 240 | 269 | 1,053 |
| Trump/Pence | 146 | 171 | 117 | 142 | 576 |
Voting by ED by party line:
Shelter Island ED #1
Joseph R. Biden and Kamala D. Harris
D votes: 232
WF votes: 12
ED Total: 246
Donald J. Trump and Michael R. Pence
R votes: 127
C votes: 19
ED Total: 146
Howie Hawkins and Angela Nicole Walker
G votes: O
Jo Jorgensen and Jeremy Cohen
L votes: 2
Brock Pierce and Karla Ballard
IN votes: 3
SI ED #2
Joseph R. Biden and Kamala D. Harris
D votes: 277
WF votes: 21
ED Total: 298
Donald J. Trump and Michael R. Pence
R votes: 159
C votes: 12
ED Total: 171
Howie Hawkins and Angela Nicole Walker
G votes: O
Jo Jorgensen and Jeremy Cohen
L votes: 5
Brock Pierce and Karla Ballard
IN votes: 1
SI ED #3
Joseph R. Biden and Kamala D. Harris
D votes:225
WF votes: 15
ED Total: 240
Donald J. Trump and Michael R. Pence
R votes: 103
C votes: 14
ED Total: 117
Howie Hawkins and Angela Nicole Walker
G votes: 2
Jo Jorgensen and Jeremy Cohen
L votes: 1
Brock Pierce and Karla Ballard
IN votes: 2
SI ED #4
Joseph R. Biden and Kamala D. Harris
D votes: 254
WF votes: 15
ED Total: 269
Donald J. Trump and Michael R. Pence
R votes: 133
C votes: 9
ED Total: 142
Howie Hawkins and Angela Nicole Walker
G votes: 1
Jo Jorgensen and Jeremy Cohen
L votes: 1
Brock Pierce and Karla Ballard
IN votes: 0
U.S. Congress
In the race for NY’s 1st Congressional District, incumbent Lee M. Zeldin, who ran on the Republican and Conservative lines, got 176,323 (61.31%) votes district-wide; challenger Nancy S. Goroff, who ran on the Democratic and Protect the Taxpayer lines, got 111,203 (38.67%).
On Shelter Island, Goroff got 996 (61.10%) votes to Zeldin’s 634 (38.89%). These are unofficial results.
| Shelter Island Election District | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Total |
| Goroff | 233 | 275 | 232 | 256 | 996 |
| Zeldin | 165 | 188 | 125 | 156 | 634 |
Voting by ED by party line:
SI ED #1
Nancy S. Goroff
D votes: 223
WF votes: 10
ED Total: 233
Lee M. Zeldin
R votes: 137
C votes: 23
IN votes: 5
ED Total: 165
SI ED #2
Nancy S. Goroff
D votes: 260
WF votes: 15
ED Total: 275
Lee M. Zeldin
R votes: 166
C votes: 16
IN votes: 6
ED Total: 188
SI ED #3
Nancy S. Goroff
D votes: 216
WF votes: 16
ED Total: 232
Lee M. Zeldin
R votes: 104
C votes: 17
IN votes: 4
ED Total: 125
SI ED #4
Nancy S. Goroff
D votes: 245
WF votes: 11
ED Total: 256
Lee M. Zeldin
R votes: 137
C votes: 18
IN votes: 1
ED Total: 156
NYS Senate
In the race for the open seat in NY’s 1st Senatorial District, Anthony H . Palumbo, who ran on the Republican and Conservative lines, got 74,293 (57.2%) votes district-wide; Laura A. Ahearn, who ran on the Democratic and Protect the Taxpayer lines, got 55,557 (42.78%).
On Shelter Island, Ahearn got 992 (62.78%) votes to Palumbo’s 588 (37.22%). These are unofficial results.
| Shelter Island Election District | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Total |
| Ahearn | 234 | 275 | 233 | 250 | 992 |
| Palumbo | 157 | 161 | 115 | 155 | 588 |
Voting by ED by party line:
SI ED #1
Laura A. Ahearn
D votes: 233
PTT votes: 1
ED Total: 234
Anthony H. Palumbo
R votes: 134
C votes: 23
ED Total: 157
SI ED #2
Laura A. Ahearn
D votes: 271
PTT votes: 4
ED Total: 275
Anthony H. Palumbo
R votes: 146
C votes: 15
ED Total: 161
SI ED #3
Laura A. Ahearn
D votes: 229
PTT votes: 4
ED Total: 233
Anthony H. Palumbo
R votes: 97
C votes: 18
ED Total: 115
SI ED #4
Laura A. Ahearn
D votes: 250
PTT votes: 0
ED Total: 250
Anthony H. Palumbo
R votes: 135
C votes: 20
ED Total: 155
NYS Assembly
In the race for NY’s 1st Assembly District, incumbent Fred W. Thiele Jr., who ran on the Democratic and Indepence lines, got 28,187 (53.32%) votes district-wide; challenger Heather C. Collins, who ran on the Republican and Conservative lines, got 24,666 (46.66%).
On Shelter Island, Thiele got 1,086 (71.03%) votes to Collins’ 443 (28.97%). These are unofficial results.
| Shelter Island Election District | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Total |
| Thiele | 265 | 320 | 267 | 280 | 1,132 |
| Collins | 124 | 115 | 81 | 123 | 443 |
Voting by ED by party line:
SI ED #1
Fred W. Thiele Jr.
D votes: 253
IN votes: 12
ED Total: 265
Heather C. Collins
R votes: 104
C votes: 20
ED Total: 124
SI ED #2
Fred W. Thiele Jr.
D votes: 300
IN votes: 20
ED Total: 320
Heather C. Collins
R votes: 102
C votes: 13
ED Total: 115
SI ED #3
Fred W. Thiele Jr.
D votes: 255
IN votes: 12
ED Total: 267
Heather C. Collins
R votes: 72
C votes: 9
ED Total: 81
SI ED #4
Fred W. Thiele Jr.
D votes: 278
IN votes: 2
ED Total: 280
Heather C. Collins
R votes: 108
C votes: 15
ED Total: 123
Justice of the Supreme Court 10th District
Voters selected eight from 10 contenders as follows:
Valerie M. Cartright | D R C IN
All district votes: 512,133 (13.22%)
SI ED #1: 350
SI ED #2: 379
SI ED #3: 308
SI ED #4: 365
SI Total: 1,402
Randy Sue Marber | D R C
All district votes: 474,944 (12.26%)
SI ED #1: 339
SI ED #2: 358
SI ED #3: 286
SI ED #4: 358
SI Total: 1,341
Bryan L. Browns | IN
All district votes: 10,161 (0.26%)
SI ED #1: 2
SI ED #2: 3
SI ED #3: 12
SI ED #4: 1
SI Total: 18
Derrick J. Robinson | D R C IN
All district votes: 482,867 (12.46%)
SI ED #1: 337
SI ED #2: 354
SI ED #3: 295
SI ED #4: 355
SI Total: 1,341
Erica L. Prager | D R C
All district votes: 476,633 (12.30%)
SI ED #1: 336
SI ED #2: 357
SI ED #3: 285
SI ED #4: 364
SI Total : 1,342
Patricia M. Blake IN
All district votes: 11,276 (0.29%)
SI ED #1: 3
SI ED #2: 6
SI ED #3: 12
SI ED #4: 1
SI Total: 22
Kathy G. Bergmann | D R C IN
All district votes: 486,641 (12.56%)
SI ED #1: 346
SI ED #2: 358
SI ED #3: 295
SI ED #4: 359
SI Total: 1,358
Joseph R. Conway | D R C
All district votes: 471,483 (12.17%)
SI ED #1: 340
SI ED #2: 346
SI ED #3: 286
SI ED #4: 352
SI Total: 1,324
Randy Berler | IN
All district votes: 10,556 (0.27%)
SI ED #1: 3
SI ED #2: 5
SI ED #3: 8
SI ED #4: 2
SI Total: 18
Timothy P. Mazzei | D R C IN
All district votes: 476,217 (12.29%)
SI ED #1: 334
SI ED #2: 346
SI ED #3: 291
SI ED #4: 344
SI Total: 2,286
Gary F. Knobel | D R C
All district votes: 449,668 (11.61%)
SI ED #1: 325
SI ED #2: 333
SI ED #3: 275
SI ED #4: 337
SI Total: 1,270
Evan Tannebaum | IN
All district votes: 10,974 (0.28%)
SI Ed #1: 4
SI Ed #2: 6
SI ED #3: 10
SI ED #4: 3
SI Total: 23
Proposals
Suffolk County voters weighed in on two proposals:
Suffolk County Proposal #1 – Shall “A Charter Law To Change The Legislative Term Of Office From Two (2) Years To Four (4) Years” be approved?
County-wide Yes: 150,264 (29.44%)
County-wdie No: 360,200 (70.56%)
| SI ED | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Total |
| Yes | 151 | 184 | 145 | 159 | 639 (42.51%) |
| No | 222 | 232 | 191 | 219 | 864 (57.49%) |
Suffolk County Proposal #2 – Shall “A Charter Law to Transfer Excess Funds in the Sewer Assessment Stabilization Reserve Fund to the Suffolk County Taxpayer Trust Fund and to Eliminate the Requirement that Interfund Transfers Be Made from the General Fund to the Sewer Assessment Stabilization Fund” be approved?
County-wide Yes: 269,475 (53.80%)
County-wide No: 231,388 (46.20%)
| SI ED | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Total |
| Yes | 151 | 171 | 142 | 185 | 649 (44.88%) |
| No | 199 | 229 | 186 | 183 | 797 (55.12%) |
Uncontested races
County-wide voting took place in two uncontested races:
County Court Judge
County-wide results
Stephen L. Braslow: 505,844
James C. Hudson: 490,242
Voting by Shelter Island ED:
| Shelter Island ED | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Total |
| Braslow | 343 | 367 | 296 | 362 | 1,368 |
| Hudson | 335 | 358 | 287 | 361 | 1,341 |
Family Court Judge
County-wide results
Caren L. Loguercio: 497,011
James W. Malone: 492,599
Voting by Shelter Island ED:
| Shelter Island ED | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Total |
| Loguercio | 339 | 368 | 288 | 357 | 1,352 |
| Malone | 342 | 359 | 285 | 355 | 1,341 |
