Mother’s Day is Sunday, May 6. If your plans include dining out (or cooking in), make your reservations (or preparations) sooner rather than later. Here are some suggestions from members of our Island Directory:
The Eccentric Bagel
The newest addition to Shelter Island’s breakfast and lunch destinations, The Eccentric Bagel is where you’ll find Mom’s new favorite artisan bagels made from scratch daily, along with fabulous cream cheese blends and a variety of classics — as well as eccentric toppings. The Eccentric Bagel is offering Mother’s Day Brunch with all the fixings for your home celebration by advance order only at hello@eccentricbagel.com. Hours: Tuesday to Sunday from 7 AM to 3 PM
631-749-5363 | 25 West Neck Road | follow us on Instagram
Eeltown Oysters
They don’t just have great oysters, they’ve also got great merch! If your mother loves oysters, stop by the stand and pick some up. But if you can’t get there, Eeltown can arrange delivery here on Shelter Island. And visit the website to check out Eeltown’s hats, hoodies, and sweatshirts — they make great gifts!
Call/text 631-949-5459 | 9 North Ferry Road | eeltownoysters.com
The Flying Goat
631-749-5404 | 26 Sunnyside Drive | flyinggoatrestaurant.com
The Islander
Every Mom knows that everyone loves The Islander! This classic family restaurant specializes in comfort food for the whole family is open daily for breakfast and lunch, and for dinner on Friday, Saturday, and Monday. Let The Islander do the home cooking on Mother’s Day, while your whole family relaxes together in the laid-back setting indoors or outdoors. The Islander now accepts Venmo, in addition to cash.
631-749-1998 | 63 North Ferry Road | theislandersi.com
Isola
If your mother loves Mediterranean specialties, look no further than Isola. While this Heights gem isn’t open Sunday, there will be live music on Friday (Greg McMullen and Friends) and Saturday (Sara Mundy), making a night out for Mom extra special. Isola strongly recommends reservations for indoor and outdoor dining. Gift cards are available, too. Hours: Tuesday to Thursday, 5 PM to 9 PM, Friday and Saturday to 10 PM
631-749-9036 | 16 Grand Avenue | isola.com
Marie Eiffel Market
Marie Eiffel offers a delightful raspberry bouquet, especially for Mother’s Day. To present a gourmet Mother’s Day meal at home, choose from prepared items — like rack of lamb, grilled branzino, poached salmon, and roasted or fried chicken — or from a selection of fresh fish and meats, gourmet cheeses, and artisanal bread. Plan to order two days in advance for specials and custom cakes. Take away, or enjoy indoor seating, or outdoors sidewalk-style or dockside overlooking Dering Harbor. Hours: Thursday to Monday, 8 AM to 6 PM
For orders, call/text Marie at 212-945-8492 | 184 N. Ferry Road | marieeiffelmarket.com
Peeko Oysters
If Mama loves oysters, drop by the Peeko Oyster Barn for some harvested daily from the pristine waters of the Little Peconic Bay. Peeko Oysters have deep-cupped bottom shells that build incredible flavor. Peekos begin with a gentle punch of freshness and end with a sweet finish.
Call/text Chris to arrange a special order, 631-408-7281 | 58 North Ferry Road | peeko-oysters/
Shelter Island Heights Pharmacy Soda Fountain
Treat Mom to a classic Soda Fountain breakfast with egg sandwiches, pancakes, and more. Or, try a lunch special along with a delicious milkshake. Alternatively, give Mom a night off with a takeout meal, available Monday and Thursday — order by 3 PM for pickup by 5 PM. Call for specials. Gift cards are available. Hours: daily from 8:30 AM to 2, on Sunday to noon.
631-749-0445 | 19 Grand Avenue | follow us on Instagram
Shelter Island IGA
Our Shelter Island IGA has EVERYTHING you need to make a delicious feast for Mom, and flowers, too! Look for special Mother’s Day items just inside the main entrance. And don’t forget to pop in Anthony Peronace’s shop for unique Shelter Island-themed gifts including a hilarious sweatshirt that’s bound to be super popular with any mother who has ever taken a child grocery shopping. The bright pink shirt featuring Peronace’s signature SPRMRKT style says: “Mom, please get me this.” Hours: daily from 7 AM to 8 PM
631-749-0382 | 75 North Ferry Road | follow the IGA on Instagram
Shelter Island Seafood
If Mom loves fresh seafood, stop by the Shelter Island Seafood market, opening this week for the season and featuring the freshest fish and shellfish. If it lives in the sea, the Shelter Island Seafood market either has it or can get it for you. The knowledgeable, friendly team can suggest the best options for what to serve, how to prepare it, and even fillet your selections for you. The seafood market opens Thursday, May 5 (the restaurant remains closed). Hours: daily from 11 AM to 6 PM
631-765-8181 | 87 North Ferry Road | shelterislandseafood.com
Shelter Island Slice
Our favorite pie at Slice is the Grandma, with its fresh homemade marinara, basil, garlic, and parmesan cheese. Check out the expanded menu with pasta dishes, soups, salads and antipasto, subs, gluten-free pizza, and desserts. Dine-in (or on the sunny patio), take away or grab a gift card to make Mom’s day! Hours: Wednesday to Saturday, 11:30 AM to 8:30 PM, Sunday, noon to 8 PM
631-749-9292 | 3 North Ferry Road | shelterislandslice.com
STARs Café
Mom will be thrilled if you order one of Lydia’s beautiful custom cakes (email starscafesi@gmail.com or text 631-680-5013 for pickup/delivery on Saturday). If you miss the Wednesday deadline, you may still find floral bouquet cupcakes, while supplies last. STARs also has gift boxes with pastries, freshly-roasted coffee beans, jams, candles, and a variety of other gift items. Or, treat Mom to the extensive classic and Tex-Mex menu for breakfast or lunch. Call for family platters and catering requests. The deadline is Wednesday, May 4. Hours: Daily, 6 AM to 4 PM, and Thursday Burger Night 5 to 7 PM
631-749-5345 | 17 Grand Avenue | starscafeshelterisland.com
Sylvester Manor Farmstand
If Mom loves the fresh selections from Sylvester Manor, you can sign her up for membership in the Community Supported Agriculture (CSA) program, which will enable her to pick up her favorite items weekly at the Farmstand all summer long. The Manor offers Pork Shares and Break Shares, too. You might prefer to buy her a Farmstand credit. Find details in this post on the Sylvester Manor website. Or, simply stop by the Farmstand. Along with just-picked produce and colorful bouquets, the Farmstand features products from local vendors, as well as fresh eggs and woodland-raised pork products. Hours: Starting this weekend, Saturday and Sunday from 10 AM to 3 PM
631-749-0626 | 21 Manwaring Road | sylvestermanor.org/our-farmstand
Vine Street Café
Guests can select from a brunch menu including local oysters and prawn cocktail, classic chicken and waffles with spicy maple syrup, as well as our VSC ultimate favorite dish carne asada hash with shredded potatoes and steak and finished with two poached eggs and hollandaise sauce. As a dessert option try the strawberry rhubarb crisp served warm with a scoop of VSC house-made buttermilk ice cream (also available at the market). For dinner, the traditional menu will be available. Reservations are recommended for dining indoors or out. Takeout and gift cards are also available. Hours: Thursday to Monday, 5 PM to 9 PM, Friday and Sunday to 10 PM, Mother’s Day Brunch, 11:30 AM to 3 PM
631-749-3210 | 41 South Ferry Road | vinestreetcafe.com
VSC Market
In addition to VSC faves, the VSC Market now offers house-crafted cocktails to go, such as Vine Street Machete, Manhattan, Negroni, and more coming soon. You can also order glasses of wine to go: rosé, white or red. In accordance with new state rules, they must be purchased with a substantial food item. Choose from grab-and-go options such as chicken salad, fried chicken, roasted BBQ chicken, and potato salad. Later this month, look for VSC Market totes from Apolis, a fair trade brand from Bangladesh. Perfect for shopping or the beach, they’re made of jute with leather handles. Hours: Thursday to Monday from 3 PM to 8 PM (until 8:30 on Friday and Saturday)
631-749-3210 ext 105 | 41 South Ferry Road — around back | vinestreetcafe.com/shop
