Wondering where to dine out Thanksgiving week on Shelter Island? Take note of what’s open and enjoy a break from the kitchen. While you’re out, think of those who might like a gift card from your favorite eatery.
These members of our Island Directory invite you to stop by during the long holiday weekend:
Vine Street Café and VSC Market
The restaurant and market will be open on Wednesday. So if you’re tired of prepping for Thursday or just don’t feel like cooking, head over to VSC and treat yourself. And, pick up some cranberry relish and apple chips from the Milk Pail to enjoy throughout the weekend. Use this link to book Vine Street Café reservations and place take-out orders.
VSC Hours: Wednesday, Friday to Monday, from 5 PM
VSC Market Hours: Wednesday, and Friday through Monday, from 3 PM to 8 PM, and until 8:30 PM on Friday and Saturday
STARs Café
STARs Café will be open daily for all-day breakfast and lunch with authentic Tex-Mex fare, as well as delish muffins and specialty coffees. Shop for branded apparel and other select gift items. Who wouldn’t like a coffee mug or bag of freshly roasted beans under the tree! Call to order for dine-in or take-out, 631-749-5345. Discount for cash purchases.
Hours: Daily from 6 AM to 4 PM, open Thanksgiving Day until 1 PM
Shelter Island Slice
Traditional pizza, gluten-free pizza, salads, and pasta dishes will fill the void after that one last turkey and stuffing sandwich! Check out weekly pizza and pasta discounts at Shelter Island Slice. Eat-in or take out. Your family and weekend guests will thank you! Use this link to order from Slice.
Hours: Wednesday, and Friday to Sunday from 11:30 AM to 8:30 PM
Shelter Island Pharmacy
The Soda Fountain at the Shelter Island Pharmacy is sure to delight out-of-town guests with iconic charm and classic fare. Breakfast and lunch are available, as well as dinner on Monday. Take out only available. Call 631-276-4596 to place your Pharmacy grill orders. Please note masks are required for entry.
Hours: Daily from 8:30 AM to 6 PM, and until 5 on Saturday and 12:30 on Sunday; closed on Thanksgiving Day
Marie Eiffel Market
In anticipation of the holiday, Marie Eiffel Market will be open daily for all your pâtisserie and gourmet needs, including a wide selection of specialty prepared foods. Or, simply enjoy a coffee or hot chocolate and a bite to eat at one of the sunny window seats. Use this link to order ahead from Marie Eiffel Market or just stop in.
Hours: Daily this week from 7 AM to 5 PM, and until 6 from Friday to Sunday, closing at 3 on Thanksgiving Day
Isola
Take a break from turkey with signature dishes from Isola that feature local ingredients with a Mediterranean flair. Brick oven truffle pizzas to the classic chicken parmesan or a juicy steak — there’s something here for everyone. Don’t miss the bar blowout on Thanksgiving Eve. Beer, wine, and cocktail specials from 9 PM to close! Call for reservations, 631-749-9036 or use this link for Isola take-out orders.
Hours: Tuesday, Wednesday, and Friday through Sunday from 5 PM to 9 PM, and until 10 PM on Friday and Saturday
The Islander
Enjoy comfort food for all the family at The Islander. Bring your crew in for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. Eat pancakes all day, any day, select an Islander burger on Monday’s Burger Night, or check out fully customizable catering options, including the Roaming Islander food truck at your event. Cash, check, or Venmo, only! Dine-in or take away. Call 631-749-1998 to place Islander orders.
Hours: Daily from 7 AM to 3 PM, and Monday, Friday, and Saturday until 8:30 PM; open Thanksgiving Day for breakfast until about 10 or 11 AM
