Find Valentine’s Day treats and eats right here on Shelter Island — from heart-shaped boxed chocolates to a family pizza party, from jewels for that special someone to caviar to share — with these options from members of our Island Directory.
Shelter Island Pharmacy
You can always rely on the Shelter Island Pharmacy for greeting cards for all occasions, including Valentine’s Day. If you’re looking for more than a card, Russell Stover boxes of chocolate are available in several sizes, including the classic heart-shaped assortment. You’ll also find balloons and sweet gift items like cozy pink slippers, body and bath products and stuffed animals.
19 Grand Avenue | 631-749-0445
Monday to Friday 8:30 AM to 6 PM, Saturday until 5 PM, and Sunday until 12:30 PM
Vine Street Café Market
The VSC Market offers John & Kira Specialty Chocolates and Hammond’s Valentine Gummies. You can also order a Valentine’s Basket with a choice of cheese and wine, a box of imported British Toast, and two Valentine’s candies. Or call for a fully-customized basket. The market is stocked with everything you need to create a special meal at home including Bolognese sauce, smoked pork ribs or salmon burgers along with unique wines and hot cocoa.
41 South Ferry Road | 631-749-3210 | Vinestreetcafe.com
Thursday to Monday, 2 PM to 8 PM
NIKKI Salon
Give a personal gift of a professional haircut or coloring for men, women or children at Nikki Salon.
“A midwinter update can really boost the winter doldrums”, says owner Nikki Ianelli.
She also offers gift cards, professional hair brushes and sumptuous organic hair products by Masami for the ultimate in botanically-hydrated hair.
8 Grand Avenue | 631-749-9400 | by appointment
Mimi Page Jewelry
Let’s face it, jewelry is a no-brainer for a romantic gift for men and women, but anyone looking for a unique gift can find a one-of-kind item at Mimi Page’s Airstream studio, Go-Go. If you’re not sure what to pick out, a gift card with Mimi is a great way to say “I love you.” Decor items and made to order pieces also available.
5 West Neck Road | 631-935-3134 | by appointment
Instagram@mimipagestudio
Shelter Island History Center Havens Store
Local artisanal gifts are in the spotlight at the Shelter Island History Center Havens Store. Find Stephanie Sareyani’s hand-painted ceramic heart mugs, Way of the Farm handmade scented candles, and Holly Cronin’s essential lavender body spray and body butter for men and women. In addition to these Valentine picks, there are puzzles, face masks, paintings, pottery, jewelry and much more.
16 South Ferry Road | 631-749-0025 ext.5 | shelterislandhistorical.org
Shop online or by appointment
Marika’s Eclectic Boutique
A furniture lover’s paradise for eclectic, designer, and vintage. Plus decor, lamps, artwork, and costume jewelry. Marika also offers re-upholstery and repainting services for pieces from home that need a fresh look. Not sure what to choose, let Marika guide you to the right gift.
6 South Ferry Road | 401-862-6607 | MarikasEclecticBoutique
Daily 9 AM to 6 PM
SIMM’S
SIMM’S Home and Fashion Boutique offers one stop shopping for men and women. Find clothing and jewelry by Marie Eiffel and other boutique designers plus home decor and gift items like books, backgammon sets, vases, candles, glasses, blankets and bedding, art, perfume and custom furnishings by Ram Design.
181 North Ferry Road | 631-786-0747 | simmssi.com
Available by appointment
Shelter Island Ace Hardware
Ace has the key to your Valentine’s heart! Do you have a special someone who loves tools? How about a chain saw or a new drill. For someone who loves canning, what about good old fashioned mason jars? Or, pick up a new grill for your grill master. You can also rely on ACE for help if you want to do something big for your Valentine — paint a room their favorite color or find storage solutions for a closet or garage. And, the Yeti collection has you covered for coolers and drinkware.
4 Grand Avenue | 631-749-0097 | facebook.com/shelterislandhardware/
7:30 to 5 PM daily, except Sundays 11 AM to 3 PM
Vine Street Café
The restaurant will be open to dine in or take away and will feature a Valentine special of steak for two with specials for sparkling wines and Prosecco. The regular menu will be available with everything from local Eel Town Oysters to duck confit .
41 South Ferry Road | 631-749-3210 | vinestreetcafe.com
Thursday to Monday, 5 PM to 8:30 PM
Isola
With the cozy glow of the wood stove creating a romantic winter atmosphere, Isola is offering a complimentary glass of bubbly for all dine-in couples and complimentary sweets for sweets after dinner to help create a memorable feast in honor of Valentine’s Day. Whether you plan to dine in or takeaway, enjoy pasta dishes or wood-fired personal pizzas, and a variety of winter specials sure to warm you, heart and soul. And this Saturday, Isola will features live music by Sara Mundy.
15 Grand Avenue | 631-749-9036 | isolany.com
Tuesday to Thursday, 5 to 9 PM, Friday and Saturday, until 10 PM
Shelter Island Slice
Everyone loves pizza, garlic knots and pasta dishes. And owner Frank Venesina will treat those who order a pasta dish one complimentary homemade cannoli for Valentine’s Day. Yum! Give the whole family a break from cooking. Order online or by phone to take away or dine in.
3 North Ferry Road | 631-749-9292 | shelterislandslice.com
Wednesday & Sunday, noon to 8:30 PM, Thursday to Saturday 11:30 AM to 8:30 PM
Marie Eiffel Market
While the market is officially closed, you can order prepared foods and groceries for weekly Friday pickup. Create a gift basket for your loved one or splurge with a tin of Russian caviar. Marie offers a special Valentine’s Day meal for two featuring shrimp cocktail, your choice of roast filet mignon, rack of lamb or whole grilled branzino, served with sweet potatoes, roasted garlic, and green salad with marinated artichoke and avocado. Dessert is tarte tatin or flourless chocolate cake. All orders are due Wednesday by 3 PM for pickup Friday between 2:30 and 4 PM, or delivery. Order online, or make special requests by text to 212-945-8492.
184 North Ferry Road | 631-749-0003 | marieeiffelmarket.com
Shelter Island IGA
We shop there so frequently, we might forget that when it comes to holidays, the IGA never lets us down. Cards? Got ’em. Flowers? They have those, too. Valentine candy? Definitely. Desserts, pastries and cookies? Yep. And, uniquely, the IGA carries one-of-a-kind apparel by Anthony Peronace! Looking to create a special meal for your sweetie? Grab some prime meats, organic produce, and even hard to find items like gluten-free flours and international foods for every taste.
75 North Ferry Road | 631-749- 0382 | facebook.com/shelterislandiga/
Daily 7 AM to 7 PM
Stars Café
Secure your loved one’s heart with homemade cakes, cupcakes or pies. Or, take it up a notch with a custom care package with items like heart shaped macaroons, homemade strawberry jam, coffee mugs, Stars ground coffee, and apparel like baby onesies or T-shirts that can be delivered locally or shipped anywhere. Gift cards are also available for breakfast and lunch or for the popular new Thursday burger night with Pepe’s own ground boneless short ribs and prime chuck burgers.
17 Grand Avenue | 631-749-5345 | starscafe.com
Southold Bay Skin Care
The unique formula of Southold Bay Skin Care is derived from a rich ingredient found in oysters called nacre, also known as mother-of-pearl. What a great gift from the sea. Nacre produces a protective moisturizing film that provides a repairing effect on damaged skin. It hydrates and moisturizes while softening the skin, increasing elasticity and supplementing nutrition for healthier, younger-looking skin. Treat yourself or your loved one to this exciting skin care product that will keep giving as your skin heals. Purchase the 50 gram jar online for $29 with free shipping.
917-232-5152 | southoldbay.com
Shelter Island Wines and Spirts
Valentine’s Day is a perfect occasion to celebrate your sweetie in style with champagne. Chill the glasses and make a toast to love. Shelter Island Wine and Spirits has a fine collection of bubbles for all budgets along with incredible wines and spirits for all tastes. Not sure what to purchase, fear not as the friendly staff will assist you in finding something that’s sure to please.
179 North Ferry | 631-749-0305
Monday to Saturday 11 AM to 7 PM, Sundays Noon to 5 PM
