Christmas worship at Island churches

Our Lady of the Isle Christmas Alter
Our Lady of the Isle Image / Christmas Alter

Shelter Island churches have announced plans for Christmas worship, keeping in mind pandemic guidelines.

Our Lady of the Isle

Our Lady of the Isle images by Eleanor P. Labrozzi
  • Christmas Eve at 4 (pageant) and 6 PM
  • Christmas Day at 9:30 AM

See more on the Our Lady of the Isle website at https://www.ourladyoftheisle.org/.


Shelter Island Presbyterian Church

  • Christmas Eve, 8 PM

Also, the Community Choir presents its annual Christmas Cantata at the church on Sunday, December 19 at 3 PM.

See more on the Presbyterian Church website at http://sipchurch.org/.


St. Mary’s Episcopal Church

St. Mary's Church
  • Christmas Eve, 5:30 PM (carols) and 6 PM
  • Christmas Day, 9:30 AM (quiet service)
  • Community Christmas Dinner, noon — deliveries only!

If you want to help out by contributing a side dish or dessert or want to have a meal delivered to your home, contact Rhonda at stmarys11964@optonline.net or 631-749-0770, ext. 2. Cash donations are appreciated too! Please mail a check to St. Mary’s PO Box 1660 Shelter Island, NY 11964 with “Christmas Dinner” in the memo line.

See more on St. Mary’s website at https://www.stmarysshelterisland.org/.